Former NFL Star Kordell Stewart: I’m Not Gay And I Never Dated The “I’m Not Gay No More” Guy

Former Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Kordell Stewart says that he’s not gay and has never dated Andrew Caldwell, the infamous “I’m not gay no more” guy – despite such claims by Caldwell, who is apparently NOT not gay no more. TMZ Sports reports:

The rumors started when Caldwell went on a radio show last week and proclaimed the two were in a secret relationship … and Stewart bought him everything from purses to expensive cars. But Stewart tells TMZ Sports … Caldwell is simply delusional — “I don’t know the guy. I’ve never heard of him.” “There’s no room in my personality for that lifestyle. It’s not what I believe in. I’m a heterosexual man.” As our friends at BSO pointed out, Caldwell shot to cyber-fame last year when he denounced his homosexuality onstage at a St. Louis church — saying, “I’m not gay no more. I am delivered. I don’t like mens no more. I like women. Women, women, women, women!” Stewart says he believes Caldwell has defamed him — but when asked if he plans to sue, the ex-Pittsburgh Steelers star says he’s not sure yet.

In 2011 Stewart married a Real Housewives Of Atlanta cast member in a ceremony that was, of course, carried on another reality show, Platinum Weddings. Stewart filed for divorce 18 months later.

  • Pollos Hermanos

    • Tulle

      Which one? The guy who makes wild ass claims on a radio show or the one that gets married on a reality show?

      • Reality.Bites


        • Jerrie Smith

          WORK AT HOME::Get $97/HOUR…I just purchased themselves a McLaren F1 when I got my check for $19993 this past 4 weeks and just over 17 thousand lass month . this is really the nicest-work Ive had . I began this 10-months ago and straight away started making more than $97… p/h .learn the facts here now
          ➤➤➤➤ http://GoogleSuperTechJobsHomeEmploymentCash/get/top… ✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱

    • Reality Check

      I wish JMG would quoted it more accurately. He said, “I’m not gay no moore. I am deliverT. I don’t like mens no moore. I like women. Women, women, women, women! – uh-duh-duh-du”

      • Joseph Miceli

        How inspirational! What a great speech. I can go on now, to live a rich and fulfilling life after having read such great oratory.
        Thank you!

      • Eebadee-eebadee-thatsallfolks

        The quote by itself, without seeing the little dance, just doesn’t do justice to his newfound heterosexuality. You really have to see the dance to get the full effect.

      • b

        I agree with people fighting gays, and I want to declare in front of everyone that: I am not gay anymore!

      • Reality Check

        Correction: The more precise quote is “I’m not gay no moore. I am deliverT. I don’t like mens no moore. I say I like women. Women!, women!, women!, women! – uh-duh-duh-du”

  • Lumpy Gaga

    Oh, Andrew, honey. Just stop.

  • Kevin Perez

    I believe Stewart although his denial could have been a lot more artful like Mike Piazza’s presser. “Love my Gay fans but I’m not gay” is the correct answer if you’re really in fact not gay.

    • Christopher

      Or, “If I were gay, I would have better taste in men than that guy. I mean, come on, look at the guys I used to shower with.”

      • Phaius

        That bow tie alone on Caldwell is enough to negate any potential for being a viable date, let alone boyfriend.

        • Christopher

          On Caldwell, I agree. But otherwise…

          • Todd20036

            Depends on the guy. Think sexy, in shape nerd
            No, I don’t wear bow ties.

          • Christopher

            I’m a sexy, sorta round shaped nerd. Does that count?

            No, I don’t own any bowties. 😉

          • Joseph Miceli

            But never this!

          • Christopher

            It looked cute on Matt Smith’s Doctor!

          • Joseph Miceli

            Yes…but only for him.

          • Kenster999

            Hey, careful! The fez is worn by some members of our community:

          • Gerry Fisher

            I luv Akbar and Jeff!

      • Gerry Fisher


    • SunsetGay

      Honestly, I’m not offended by his response. He probably felt like a deer in the headlights when he saw this. Being an NFL star and having a rumor like this (especially with a weirdo like Caldwell) could sink a person’s entire reputation. People are also very gullible and will believe everything they hear these days.

      My guess is he didn’t get much of an opportunity to discuss this with a PR person.

      • Chucktech

        And his ruminations about suing for “defamation”? Fuck him.

        • Reality.Bites

          As long as the lawsuit says the defamation is that he dated Caldwell and had to pay for it, I’m good with him suing.

          Of course Caldwell doesn’t have a cent to his name, so it”s a bit pointless.

          • SunsetGay

            Yes, he was spending all his remaining cents at Bachmann’s clinic in Minnesota to “likes womenz”

        • NeverEclipsed81

          he certainly could be more sympathetic to the gay community in this, but the fact is it does defame his career because of all the bigoted NFL watchers. it’s ashame but it’s true, and this is clearly a lie.

          • DaveW

            Bigoted homophobes like to watch sweaty muscular guys “in contact “. I have always been skeptical.

      • Toasterlad

        Kordell Stewart hasn’t been an NFL “star” for 10 years…and he was never that great a player. More importantly, I’d hoped we’d gotten beyond the point where gay rumors could “sink a person’s entire reputation”. It’s annoying that Stewart feels being perceived as gay is something to be ashamed of; it’s even worse that some gay people have sympathy for that viewpoint.

        • Xuuths

          Here’s a hint: If you’re being considered for the next season of Dancing with the Stars, then you’re a has-been.

      • NeverEclipsed81

        it’s an obvious lie he has every right to be pissed. this fool didn’t mess around with a pittsburgh steeler,

      • Joseph Miceli

        I’m going to have to lovingly call you on that. It “could sink a person’s entire reputation” is a phrase full of internalized homophobia. If being called gay is a misrepresentation of who he is, fine. A person’s reputation does not hinge on his sexuality. It hinges on his character. My character is not impacted because I am a homosexual. The proper response would be, ” No, I am not gay. I have no sexual interest in men. Obviously, this person is unhinged and looking for attention. I refuse to give it to him.”

  • Blake Jordan

    No F’s to be given over either of these men.

  • Octavio

    Whew. Now I can sleep at night. Thanks for clearing that up.

  • Phil Touchette

    Andrew…bitch please. We’ve seen you out at the clubs. We’ve seen you at the local bathhouse. Stop with this charade.

    • sherman

      And I assume avoided him at the bath.

      • Reality.Bites

        All I know is that’s a mighty fancy car and mighty pretty purse that Phil has.

  • Lumpy Gaga

    Gayer than an airkiss from Iwan.

    (No, I will NOT stop trying to make this happen.)

  • geoffalnutt

    That’s the funniest thing I’ve seen today. We’re very nearly in “I’m not gay and neither is my boyfriend” territory…sort of. By the way, Kordell – ‘belief’ has nothing to do with it…or anything else, for that matter…except mental illness.

  • Rick

    Oh brother. ‘Lifestyle.’ I thought that term went the way of the Jheri Curl.

  • Lumpy Gaga

    I don’t believe in small dicks.

    • kanehau

      Just small pricks 🙂

  • Michael Rush

    I’m not gay but my boyfriend who buys my purses is .

    • Sk3ptic

      I’m not gay but the boyfriend I buy purses for is.

    • Todd20036

      Of course I’m not gay. I only fuck men because it’s convenient, and I never kiss.
      Personally, I’m being snarky, but lots of people probably feel that way

      • MonochromeMouse

        it’s only gay if you kiss and/or the balls touch, otherwise it’s basically just masturbation

      • Joseph Miceli

        Oh my! I could tell you stories about the Marines I’ve known back in my 20’s. I think Mommie Dammit has a few to tell also.

  • Michael

    If TMZ was smart, they would hunt down local police reports on Kordell “Slash” Stewart back when he was still playing for the Steelers. Hint: domestic disturbance

  • TJay229 This cartoon tickles me.

  • Toasterlad

    I believe Stewart is gay, but I don’t believe he’d date Caldwell…he’s got better taste than that, if not integrity.

  • Christopher

  • MikeBx2

    I felt bad that Stewart had been pulled into that nuts delusions until I read that, like most homophobic, possibly closeted, men, he has reduced us to a “lifestyle” and felt the need to say “It’s not what I believe in”. Maybe he’s getting what he deserves.

  • On behalf of the gay community I would like to impart a special dispensation on both Kordell Stewart and Andrew Caldwell. In the future, please feel free to consider yourselves not gay, whether it’s true or not.

  • Blobby

    “Star”? Well, THAT is a stretch.

  • NeverEclipsed81

    Only delusional dingbats would believe that guy could ever get with an NFL player.. Of course that’s his target audience so he wins that way. But no, I don’t think he dated a Pittsburgh Steeler when he was “gay”.

    • Jonathan

      I think you may be lost… Breitbart is over there ———>

      Edit: actually I’m lost. Completely misunderstood your post on the first read. Mea culpa

      • NeverEclipsed81

        I’m a gay democrat so no Breitbart for me. Lol thanks for clarifying

  • BearEyes

    and it’s still not a “lifestyle”

    • DumbHairyApe

      Hanging draperies, arranging flowers, picking out accessories, baking rainbow cakes, farting glitter, looking in the bushes for needy men…if this isn’t a lifestyle, I don’t know what is.

      • olandp

        Not all gay men do all those things. I myself hang draperies, arrange flowers, and pick out accessories. I could bake a rainbow cake if I had a mind to, but farting glitter sounds painful and I’ve never looked for a man in the bushes.

        • Bud Evans

          ~ On the Queenzy Scale that would be a three:

          (1) Complete Slob. Cultivates Fungi as a Hobby. Turns underwear inside-out to gain a few more weeks before laundering.

          (2) Still Waiting for Mom to Pick Up After, But Will Clean Up – if Necessary. Very compatible with #3.
          (PS –That would be me.)

          (3) Tidy and Capable, But Not Neurotic About it. Gives their life more of a purpose when they’re living with #2.
          (PS- That would be my man-spouse.)

          (4) Neat Freak and Fussy About Stuff. Tapes up lowest hanging testicle to make both look symmetrical, and then has trouble crossing legs. But can be practical too — collects dust on furniture for later use as potting soil.

          (5) Obsessive Compulsive About Absolutely Anything Fabulous — Also Collects Cats and Judy Garland Memorabilia. But if born after 1980, collects Madonna Memorabilia and stuffed toys wearing ass-less chaps..


          Special note: shopping for bushmen, optional in all categories.

          • Dan Robinson


        • DaveW

          I prefer the trees. Bushes rustle too much.

          Cooking and draperies should not be gender specific, IMHO. sadly it is homophobia that makes it so

          And yes I make my own curtains and they are fabulous.

  • “There’s no room in my personality for that lifestyle.” – whatever, just *Huh?* I’m not even sure what that means.

    • Rick

      I think it’s something like saying, “There’s no room in my house for that Ikea kitchen table,” when what you really mean to say is, “Goddamn! That Ikea kitchen table is ugly,” which in his case would be just another way of saying, “As long as I’m ashamed about it, I’m still not gay.”

  • S B

    Would he have been defamed if that idiot called him left-handed? Or blonde? I hope in my lifetime calling someone gay becomes a non-actionable non-insult.

    • Dan Robinson

      Hear hear!

  • DB

    There’s a very easy way for Caldwell to prove it. Show TMZ the expensive cars and other luxury goods that Stewart purchased. Heck, forget about the other goods, just show title to 1 expensive car.

    • and here I’m just thinking a cock pic would suffice

  • Jmdintpa

    one word ….WHATEVER

    • justmeeeee

      that’s two words, mary, WHAT….EVAH!!!!!!

  • jomicur

    The rumors about Stewart started way earlier than last week. When he was the Steelers QB there were rumors all over town about him living on the down-low and hitting on guys. There were even rumors that he got busted twice for having sex in a local park’s gay cruising area. The Steelers moved heaven and hell to quash the rumors (threatened lawsuits, etc.), but they persisted till Stewart left the team.

    • ChitownKev

      Yep…and those rumors followed him here to Chicago; Kordell Stewart was pretty much the Aaron Rodgers of the 1990’s

  • StSean


  • Greg B.

    Apparently Jeebus’ salvation can wear off after a few months.

    • Sounds like a jeebus infection. Those do tend to wane and finally clear the system after a while, except for those who have a terminal case, and then its incurable.

    • Dan Robinson

      It does. I had it and it went away. Now I kneel before the altar of….mphlpth..

  • stanhope

    I don’t doubt that the Grand Duchess of Piedmont Park never dated Andrew Caldwell. Two queen bottoms can never rule the same territory. It is time for Andrew Caldwell to be over and put down the fork

  • MattM

    “There’s no room in my personality for that lifestyle. It’s not what I believe in. I’m a heterosexual man.”
    I can believe I’m truly heterosexual all I want. Doesn’t change the fact that I’m as gay as a Cher-themed nativity scene.

    • Tor

      I had an acquaintance who collected nativity scenes, everything from traditional antique ones to ones populated by only dogs. She’d love a Cher-themed one!

      • MattM

        Scrounge up some gays and make it happen! We can do this!

        • clay

          imagine the discussion regarding which Bob Mackie outfit goes with which character.

          • Oh my, it could get very very ugly!

      • JD

        Would that mean that Chas is the newborn messiah?

  • weirdest thing i’ll likely read all week

    • JCF

      Week is still young.

  • TedCrewz

    He won’t sue for defamation due to the fear of factual evidence being presented that would show otherwise.

    • Reality.Bites

      Evidence he’s gay in no way validates the claim they were together. Unless they actually were

      • TedCrewz

        I’m not thinking in terms of evidence that he is homosexual, I’m thinking of evidence that they were involved in a relationship. Even a simple text or email could verify that. I’m thinking that there may be more to this story than we think. There always is.

  • bambinoitaliano

    Nothing to see here. Not gay and no gay no more equal zero gay. See I’m still good with math.

  • My personal advice would be to yes, sue the jerk for defamation and put an end to his public claim. Slap him with a $50,000 judgment, garnishee any income and property and keep at it for the next ten years until the judgment is paid. If he doesn’t take legal action Stewart’s denial will always be suspect.

  • justmeeeee

    small correction: he wasn’t delivered. he was delivert!

  • TexPlant

    Who and Who?

  • Platos_Redhaired_Stepchild

    He’s like the Wizard of Oz. “Pay no attention to that man on his knees behind the curtain.”

  • JD

    Back when I lived in Western PA (1998-2006), it was a well-known rumor that Kordell Stewart frequented the Fruit Loop, a cruising area. Can anyone confirm this?

  • Gerry Fisher

    >There’s no room in my personality for that lifestyle. It’s not what I believe in.

    Hon, beliefs have nothing to do with it. Ya ahhr or you ahhrn’t.

  • JVB

    He don’t like mens no mor’. He likes wimmen, wimmen, wimmen.

  • Jean-Marc in Canada

    There’s just so much D’uh going on here…..I really don’t know how to comment.

  • JCF

    Hmmm, whom do I DISBELIEVE more???

  • ChitownKev

    Two separate issues. Miss Caldwell is an attention whore and I doubt that Kordell Stewart would be bothered with that kind of mess.

    OTOH, Miss Kordell need not be so insistent…of course Kordell has always been that way

  • Jerrie Smith

    WORK AT HOME::Get $97/HOUR…I just purchased themselves a McLaren F1 when I got my check for $19993 this past 4 weeks and just over 17 thousand lass month . this is really the nicest-work Ive had . I began this 10-months ago and straight away started making more than $97… p/h .learn the facts here now
    ➤➤➤➤ http://GoogleSuperTechJobsHomeEmploymentCash/get/top… ✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱✱

  • DaveW

    It’s a sad commentary on our culture when we call athletes stars.