GEORGIA: GOP State Rep Defends Her Suggestion To Quarantine HIV+ People: I Was Just Being Provocative

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reports:

Georgia Rep. Betty Price said her comments on people with HIV that ignited a national firestorm this week were “taken completely out of context.” Price, the wife of former U.S. health secretary Tom Price, was in a study committee Tuesday when she asked a state health official whether people with HIV could legally be quarantined.

Price said she was just being “provocative.” She said she is not in favor of a quarantine but made the “rhetorical” statement because she was sad and troubled that “too many of our fellow citizens who have HIV are not compliant.”

Here’s that “out of context” quote:

“I don’t want to say the quarantine word, but I guess I just said it. Is there an ability, since I would guess that public dollars are expended heavily in prophylaxis and treatment of this condition? So we have a public interest in curtailing the spread. What would you advise or are there any methods legally that we could do that would curtail the spread?”

“It seems to me it’s almost frightening, the number of people who are living that are potentially carriers. Well they are carriers, with the potential to spread, whereas in the past they died more readily and then at that point they are not posing a risk. So we’ve got a huge population posing a risk if they are not in treatment.”

Price is a medical doctor and is married to former HHS Secretary Tom Price, who resigned last month after a private jet scandal.

  • Lazycrockett

    Is it too early in the morning to call someone a bitch?

    • JAKvirginia


      • Todd N. Law

        Or, a misanthropic piece of garbage. Because, well, swearing isn’t very lady-like and I wouldn’t want to offend the bitch.

    • Richie Kau

      No, it is not.

    • La Cieca

      Not when the “c” word is more appropriate.

      • cleos_mom

        Not comfortable with the demonization of female genitalia. “Canker sore” would fit just as well.

    • Robincho

      Start with bitch, and as the morning wanes you can work up from there…

    • Adam King

      If it’s le mot juste one has no choice.

    • aagold76 .

      I just sent her an email saying exactly that… [email protected]

      • JackFknTwist

        Thanks for the contact address; I have made myself very clear on her squalid, malicious rant.

        What a f ucking fool.

        • RoFaWh

          I hope in the process of making yourself clear you used the same words, squalid and malicious.

          • JackFknTwist

            i confirm that I did use those words. And I did sign my name .

    • fuow

      It’s never to early to call this pus-filled C*NT what she is. Just, maybe an insult to female dogs.

    • j.martindale

      You are a couple of days late by my calendar.

    • JackFknTwist

      It is never too early for calling out a fascist a sshole
      never too early for a gin and tonic.

  • bkmn
    • Matt

      I love this. I also know what it’s actually for, but I still love it.

      • Lars Littlefield

        University of Nevada Tech?

      • Bubba in TX

        University of North Texas, I believe.

        • Ragnar Lothbrok

          University of Not Trump

          • Bubba in TX

            Or that.

          • RoFaWh

            I wish someone would conduct a careful study of Trump’s time at U. Penn and smoke out the probable truth that his “degree” was simply paid for by daddy.

          • clay

            There was a reporter who did basically that, but was unable to obtain transcripts. The gist is that he was an average student (not adequate to move on to an MBA) who was only interested in those courses directly tied to real estate negotiations. Also– he never had a second date with anyone at the school, and expressed no opinion about the (for the first time in his life and the school’s life) presence of female classmates, or any opinions about the war (out of which school was keeping him) despite his military school background the visible presence of the First Troop Philadelphia Cavalry.

    • lattebud

      I hope the user is righthanded so others are notified.

  • margaretpoa

    I think you ought to shit in your hair and call it curls. But no offense. Don’t go taking that out of context.

  • Ragnar Lothbrok

    Godddamed ignorant hateful bitch

  • greenmanTN

    No, you were just being a word I can’t write here because it’s banned. But it rhymes with punt.

  • Slippy_World
  • Paula

    Provocative? Oh baby, it worked. I am seriously provoked. Bitch!

    • Adam King

      Oops. Great minds.

    • Statistics Palin

      The b-word and the c-word aren’t sufficiently nasty for Betty Price. There needs to be a z-word.

      • RoFaWh


        It’s not a real word but it does start with a “z”.

    • Uncle Mark

      I would ask her if she ever sipped of the ‘milk of human kindness,’ but clearly she’s lactose intolerant

    • Uncle Mark

      “Provocative?!!” Is this her pusillanimous way of saying “just kidding?” You know…like when horrible people say something utterly despicable and get called out on it, but lack the testicular fortitude to stand by their statement?

      • kareemachan

        “I’m sorry you took it the way you did.”

        • Uncle Mark

          Good one !! The non-apology “apology”

      • kaydenpat

        Conservatives and humor just don’t go together. And there’s nothing “provocative” about wishing HIV patients dead.

      • cleos_mom

        As I recall, “it’s a spoof” was the canned defense of choice in the pop music universe during the 80s.

  • MBear

    What a horrid person

    • Galvestonian

      ‘horrid’ is too kind.

      • MBear

        I typed that with an English accent, which i think is stronger than the American usage…? 😉

        • jerry

          That would be “What an ‘orrid person”.

      • BudClark

        “Terrifying” …

  • vorpal 😼

    “What would you advise or are there any methods legally that we could do that would curtail the spread?”

    Here’s something actual helpful instead of a foray into rampant idiocy:
    Make PrEP affordable and available to many more people for starters?

    • Chucktech

      That would mean making healthcare available to more people. Can’t have that…

      • vorpal 😼

        Exactly. And if employers are allowed to deny women contraceptive medication on the grounds of religious idiocy, it’s not going to be long before employers are allowed to deny gay men HIV treatment medication and PrEP on the grounds of religious idiocy.

        • clay

          Expect HPV vaccine to show up on that list, as well.

    • RMJ

      Image the outrage if we said:

      “So we have a public interest in curtailing the spread. What would you advise or are there any methods legally that we could do that would curtail the spread of Christianity?”

      “It seems to me it’s almost frightening, the number of people who are living that are potentially carriers. Well they are carriers, with the potential to spread, whereas in the past they died more readily by being fed to the lions and then at that point they are not posing a risk. So we’ve got a huge population posing a risk if they are not dead.”

      I got some provocative for you bitch!

      • RoFaWh

        I would approve of outlawing the bible, including mere possession of a copy. Burn them.

        • RMJ

          Isn’t it interesting in the movie “The book of Eli” the trailer describes the movie as “A post-apocalyptic tale, in which a lone man fights his way across America in order to protect a sacred book that holds the secrets to saving humankind.”

          But the entire premise of the movie is that Eli arrives in a ramshackle town rebuilt and overseen by Carnegie (Gary Oldman). Carnegie dreams of building more towns and of controlling the people by using the power of a certain book.

          The Bible and most religious texts can be summed up similar to that, they promise the secrets to saving humankind but ultimately are only a means of controlling the people. And a VERY successful means of control I might add. I’m paraphrasing the original I read somewhere:

          “There is no atrocity, nor evil deed committed with such glee as those committed in the name of one’s religion”

    • Ninja0980

      Not to mention better sex education.

      • vorpal 😼

        Agreed. The Christian “right” acts like teaching children about sex – let alone anal sex, which plenty of heterosexuals do and is not the “homosex sin” they think it exclusively is – is a bad thing, but their kids ARE engaging in these activities. They’re horny pre-teens / teens and you might want them to wait until heterosexual marriage, but did YOU, heterosexual parents? Probably not, and they’re almost certainly not going to.

        Nobody is made worse for learning how to do these activities safely.

        Ignorance, on the other hand, is what causes people to unknowingly engage in stupid and harmful activities.

        • RoFaWh

          It’s the old old problem of someone ignoring human nature while spinning their totalitarian fantasies.

          Much like tax laws: I’ve seen someone with important influence over them completely ignore the not-so-minor detail that no matter how well crafted those laws are, people will find the loopholes and exploit them to the max.

    • zhera

      Putting money into reasearch and finding a vaccine would be nice. And PrEP in the meantime. Sex education. Free condoms at all clinics, hospitals, and doctors.

      • RoFaWh

        Free condoms in all high schools, both junior and senior if the distinction is made. In 4-4-4 systems, middle schools would be included.

  • Leo

    OT. Looks like the ‘simmering’ culture war on race might be boiling.

    • Adam King

      Sherrod Brown is about the only thing that leaves me not-ashamed of being from Ohio.

      • Gustav2

        There has to be ONE Ohio Republican that doesn’t make you ashamed?


        • Adam King

          Not one.

        • Tawreos

          You’d think so, but you’d be wrong.

        • Todd20036

          Any republican that I might not have been ashamed of is now either a democrat or independent.

    • Danieruw

      “SEEMS to be”? “Is!!!!”

    • Mike_in_the_Tundra

      I really appreciate Sen. Brown. He says what needs to be said. He’s not always saying the things that will get him contributions.

  • Lakeview Bob

    I can’t start going off a rant on Sunday morning. I just can’t.

  • Harveyrabbit

    Right. “Provocative”.

    Discussing alternative treatment for a disease would be provocative. Suggesting new modes of transportation for city living would be provocative. Suggesting sending sick people to a concentration camp is not provocative it’s, dare I say it and go all Godwin, Nazi-like.

    • MBear

      It’s time to drop the Godwin and accept it as good old fashioned murrikkkan fascism

      • Falconlights

        You took the keystrokes right out of my fingers! It’s time to throw that rule OUT!

        • MBear

          I think the consensus had been suspension: the thread is not over.

          But i think murrikkkan fascism is entrenched enough to secure its own brand without seeming so derivative, regardless of any symbol repetition

      • cleos_mom

        Godwin is like Occam’s Razor: a commonsense rule of thumb that people with certain challenges often mistake for an immutable law of physics.

  • Adam King

    Okay, I’m provoked. Good job, bitch.

  • No you were speaking your mind. An evil mind to be sure but you were being honest in how you felt. People like you should NEVER hold power.

  • bambinoitaliano

    The shameful thing about this is, these elected fucking morons require the media, the social media to school them on how to behave when it’s suppose to be the reverse.

  • DaddyRay

    The most disturbing part of that comment was “whereas in the past they died more readily and then at that point they are not posing a risk.”

    • BearEyes

      they really do want us dead.

      • Xiao Ai: The Social Gadfly

        Every last one of us. I never forget that. And, I don’t forget anyone who waffles on us for political reasons either.

        • Debby

          Google is paying 97$ per hour,with weekly payouts.You can also avail this.
          On tuesday I got a great new Land Rover Range Rover from having earned $11752 this last four weeks..with-out any doubt it’s the most-comfortable job I have ever done .. It sounds unbelievable but you wont forgive yourself if you don’t check it
          ➽➽;➽➽ http://GoogleOnlineEasyCreativeTechJobsOpportunities/easy/jobs ★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫:::::!tp66luuuuu

      • SFBruce

        But only in the interest of public health.

        • Like the mentally ill in early ’30s Germany, amirite?

          • David Walker

            Never happen. In the fucking moron’s Murka mentally ill people are allowed to have guns.

          • cleos_mom

            If the Religious Reich follows the historic pattern, they’ll be claiming that extermination is ‘for the protection of the homosexuals as well.’

      • kareemachan

        Not to mention all the babies who contracted it from their mothers, the people who got it from hetero sex partners, the people who were raped and got it from their rapist, etc, etc, etc.

        And here I thought these were all pro-life good xtians.

        • Duck

          “Pro-life” is a misnomer. When someone says they are “pro-life” they really mean they are pro-forced birth to punish that whore for daring to have sex.

      • Judas Peckerwood

        Well, it’s mutual, as least as far as I’m concerned.

    • Steverino

      Ah yes, the good ole days, when gay men would just drop dead.

      • Lars Littlefield

        Fun times. /s

    • The_Wretched

      Exactly. There isn’t any context that fixes that.

      • SFBruce

        The only context which would fix this starts with, “Only a completely heartless idiot would say something like…”

    • marshlc

      Yeah, that just jumped out, didn’t it. She’s a fucking psychopath.

      • DaddyRay

        Seriously – what sane person thinks that way

      • Goodboy

        She kind of reminds me of this character. Well, in say twenty or so years.

        • xzargo

          20 or so years? What are you smoking? Price is already a disgusting smelly crazy old hag.

          • Goodboy

            Ha. Yeah, I messed that one up. I meant Kathy Bates charactor might look like her if they aged and uglified her.

    • Goodboy

      Jesus Christ. You know the other psychopath feels the same damn way and he was the health and human services secretary.

      • zhera

        I wonder what that’s like, two psychopaths being married. Are they psychopathing together or are they constantly trying to tear each other down?

        • Westcoast88

          I’m glad they’re together. They deserve each other. Why wreck two marriages?

    • Nic Peterson

      Just looking at her, I would have thought all of the ugly was on the outside.

      • 3-Star

        She should be quarantined and her hairdresser too!

    • Buford

      That’s bad, but the MOST disturbing part is their willingness to brainstorm such drastic measures in the interest of public safety regarding the spread of HIV when they otherwise refuse to even allow ANY discussion on the epic US public safety crisis of ‘guns’.

      In the US, guns kill 3x the number of people who die from HIV/AIDS. So while I generally encourage bold ideas in the interest of public safety, the spread of HIV is not where the bold action is needed.

    • Sporkfighter

      Cut her some slack. All she meant was that the dead are not at risk of dying. Surely we can agree that eliminating the risk of death among our HIV brothers and sisters is a good thing, right?

      /Sarcasm is my super power./

    • kaydenpat

      Such a nice, Christian woman. /s

    • Oh, Parker

      Sick, depraved person.

  • Matt

    She meant every word she said. Every. Last. Word. Another dipshit conservative who doesn’t understand the concept of “recording devices.”

    • Chucktech

      She didn’t know someone was running a tape recorder…

  • Ben in Oakland

    Provocative, in christofasciorepublispeak…

    “I was so surprised that people thought I was actually a horrible person instead of a savior.”

  • Reasonoverhate

    It was bad enough when I just knew her husband is a doctor. But she’s a doctor too??? And thinks like this? What the actual fuck? See you next Tuesday, Bitch!

  • Bluto

    This wasn’t a provocation. Rationing health care & suggesting concentration camps is full blown, unequivocal nazi evil.

    • MBear

      *murrikkkan evil

      Time to update those references.

  • DaddyRay

    It is highly disturbing her and her husband are in our Government

    • lattebud

      And they were elected

  • JRDC

    A doctor said this. MDs are assholes and people are too intimidated by them. She’s a real fucking c u n t.

    • BudClark

      SOME MDs …

  • Joe in PA

    Must not use a bad word, must not use a bad word….

    • Xiao Ai: The Social Gadfly

      Do it! Just use an alt-character in there somewhere, if it’ll make you feel better. 😉

      • Joe in PA

        I hear ya, I was typing in deference to StraightGrandMother, she hates the C word. But GD, even she has to want to use that word to describe a person like this. 🙁

        • Xiao Ai: The Social Gadfly

          I love, and respect, Str8Grandmother. But, no one agrees on everything, and there’s just no better word to encapsulate people like Price.

    • Acronym Jim

      Is it Tuesday already?

      • Joe in PA

        You mean Next Tuesday. 🙂

  • Acronym Jim

    “whereas in the past they died more readily and then at that point they are not posing a risk.”

    And yet, when we were “dying more readily,” those living with HIV were posing MORE of a risk. With treatment and living longer with an undetectable viral load, those living with HIV pose much less of a “risk” than in those halcyon days of ignoring the problem in the hopes that we would all die out. In fact, that risk is getting closer and closer to nil every week.

    The AMA should revoke her medical degree.

    • Chucktech

      She’s not in the biz anymore. She’s got a new racket goin’.

    • iambu

      You stop it with that common sense and accuracy right now!

      • Acronym Jim

        I can’t help it; it’s just a knee-jerk reaction on my part.

  • Gustav2

    Thank goodness she didn’t use the Trump excuse of “joking.”

    • Joe in PA

      So there’s that. 🙁

      • Gustav2

        Yeah, that glass is 1/8th full.

    • Stogiebear

      She couldn’t have been joking. She was “sad and troubled” at the time. Poor her. All those nasty sick people not being able to afford treatment. Let’s just round them up and put them in extermination camps so she can go through her days in sunshine and happiness.

      • Gustav2

        I’m sure she would support privately owned, but government funded, extermination camps.

        • Adam King

          As long as it doesn’t interfere with tax cuts for the wealthy and for corporations, of course.

  • Xiao Ai: The Social Gadfly

    I’ll put her ass in quarantine, fucking [email protected]

  • Sam_Handwich
    • Gustav2

      AND they had a child.

  • DaddyRay

    1.1 million people in the US are living with HIV
    She really thinks put 1.1 million people in quarantine for the rest of their lives is an option?

    • Chucktech

      Since practically none of them are Republicans, sure.

  • greenmanTN
  • Treant

    You were just being that word I’m not supposed to use here. Sit down, shut up, and do your fucking job representing all of your constituents, you moronic dolt.

  • Joe in PA

    I’ve been enjoying SPECTACULAR fall day here in eastern PA…the first time I log on to JMG…damn there is a lot of shit this am. 🙁

    (not picking on JMG, the comments make it all worthwhile.)

    • Treant

      73 and sunny! It was a tad warm yesterday and again today, but I still got about fifteen percent of the garden cleaned out.

      • Joe in PA

        I know! I hurt my foot this week, so I’ve been slowly working my way out in the garden. Dang, getting old sucks! I’ve got stuff to do. 🙂

        • Treant

          Yeah, I wrenched my knee again yesterday. I could barely get laid last night.

          • Robincho

            You should take a knee. From someone else…

          • Joe in PA

            Now, I mean this in the nicest way. Slut.


          • Treant

            Why thank you! That’s the nicest thing anybody’s said to me since last night when I was called “Tiger.”

          • BudClark


            Love it!

      • Ragnar Lothbrok

        I usually clean the veg garden in the fall as I use it to burn 8.4 billion leaves. The flower gardens I leave to provide habitat for winter residents.
        Expecting a hard freeze later this week, so I dug up and potted one of my Nerium oleanders.

        • Treant

          I mow all the leaves into the lawn (it’s good organic material), but…2000 square feet of dead plant is a bit much even for me. 🙂 I’ll leave some for winter interest and I shake off all the seeds into the gardens for the birds (most are tropical or sub-tropical and the seed won’t survive the winter).

          I also pot things up! I have two orange, one yellow, and one hybrid orange-yellow marigold potted to bring indoors. They were September-sprouting volunteers. I also added an ageratum, and a dwarf zinnia to the mix.

          They should bloom indoors until January or so.

    • djcoastermark

      Still hot and humid here. It’s 88 already and it’s not even noon.

      • Joe in PA

        Ugh, Florida, right?

        • djcoastermark

          ayup. A few cooler days would be nice. Might get some next week. At least it doesn’t get cold enough for frost, but jeez, the heat these past few years.

          • BudClark

            I’m not at ALL sure that we’re up for another California desert summer, unless the landlord puts in a MUCH bigger a/c.

      • BudClark

        It’s still hot in the CA desert during the day, but cooler in the early morning and late evening.

    • Tawreos

      Probably a good idea to go back out and continue to enjoy the weather. I just finished the lawn and am about to go walk the dog.

      • Joe in PA

        Yup, I think that’s a great idea for both of us!

    • Adam King

      Here too. Perfect.

    • Ragnar Lothbrok

      Storms last night. Another 2 inches of rain on already saturated soil.

      I need to mow, but….. I want the wind to scour the leaves away first 🙂

      • Joe in PA

        Yikes. Aren’t you in Des Moines? I thought you were suffering from a drought? Hmmm.

        • Ragnar Lothbrok

          No, I am in the ” Promised Land ” between DSM and Omaha.

          ( Promise of death by boredom )

          The drought is / was South of DSM . We were borderline drought mid summer, but that changed with a 6 inch rain in August and a very wet fall.
          Harvest is a week or 2 behind.

          • Joe in PA

            I just re-read you comment…a 6 inch rain? Yikes, and that was without a hurricane behind it. Wow.

            I knew some folks that rode RAGBRAI. They tell me Iowa is anything but flat. 🙂 How did you come to call home Iowa?

          • Ragnar Lothbrok

            My entire family on both sides settled here to farm. I left a few times, then returned.

    • BudClark

      I’ve been in and out of hospital all week … I DREADED turning the computer “on” when I got home.

      • Joe in PA

        I hate to “up vote” you comment, but you know what I mean.

        So sorry you’ve had a hospital-full week. 🙁 You must be better, I hope. But think of it this way, you were spared a week of Trump shenanigans. Continued recovery buddy!

  • Tawreos

    I guess making comprehensive sex education and condoms freely available is just to difficult, but quarantining people is just fine.

    • DaddyRay

      Obviously the answer is to send Bristol Palin out on more Abstinence Only education tours

      • Tawreos

        Why, does she need another kid?

        • Stogiebear

          That aspirin between her knees is almost dissolved from her sweaty thighs.

  • ChrisMorley

    ‘The Republican lawmaker and former anesthesiologist said a health official had presented data showing Georgia as second only to Louisiana in the rate of new infections.

    Part of the reason is that more than a third of Georgians with HIV are not receiving care for it. She said that’s what sparked her comments.’

    But she then blames people on HIV treatment for not taking it properly, but quotes no evidence to show this is even a problem in Georgia:

    ‘Price said she is not in favor of a quarantine but made the “rhetorical” statement because she was troubled that “too many of our fellow citizens who have HIV are not compliant with the effective treatment of this now chronic disease.”

    • RoFaWh

      She’s just making shit up.

  • This is my state rep (ugh), and I sent several messages to her office letting her know what I think of all this.

    • SoCalGal20

      When is she up for reelection? Does she have an opponent?

      • Next year, since it’s the state house. I don’t know if she has an opponent yet (she didn’t last November), but if she does, I will support them and give them money to help get her out of the Georgia House of Reps.

        • SoCalGal20

          Good! I hope somebody is running against her!

  • SoCalGal20

    So with a rise of other communicable diseases like TB, should all those people also be in quarantine? GA had one of the higher per capita rates of TB in 2015.

  • aagold76 .

    give her a shout out

    [email protected]

    couldn’t find a twitter, etc for her- but state site has email links

  • DaddyRay

    But remember folks: Both parties are the same

  • Lawerence Collins

    No, you were feeding the GOP thugs so called Christian Right base. With new ways of tormenting hiv positive people

  • fuow

    Yup, this is the government we get when we stay home or vote ‘Green’ to protest Democrats not being perfect.
    What a fucking C*NT.
    *The asterisk is because some unique snowflakes around here object to calling people by their proper name.

    • DaddyRay

      What do we call her husband

      • fuow

        I’d rather not call him at all. He turned the Hippocratic Oath into the Hypocritical Oath.

    • DaddyRay

      While those Democrats agreed with their positions 99.9% of the time it was that .1% that was just so important that they had to teach the Democratic Party a lesson

      • fuow

        Yup. We Democrats fall in love.
        Rethuglicans fall in line.
        Until we learn that, we will continue to win ‘moral’ victories all the way to the new Auschwitz Anlage.

  • Steverino

    What she calls “provocative,” I call a cunning stunt.

    • fuow

      I love what you did. See You Next Tuesday!

    • Treant

      Is she short enough to call a cunning runt?

      • Steverino

        If she runs for office again…

  • bambinoitaliano
  • Chucktech

    “I Was Just Being Provocative Christian.”

  • realspear

    So is “provocative” an excuse for any outrageous bigotry?

    • MBear

      It’s a word most of her constituents wont understand

    • Treant

      Yes. Any threat or insult is perfectly OK as long as you say it’s “provocative” or “a joke” afterward. At some companies and in some Republican legislatures, you can even use that as an excuse for assault.

      At one company I worked at, a 300-pound supervisor body-slamming a 150-pound employee into a desk or wall was called “a joke” and excused by HR.

      • RoFaWh

        Did you show them the bills for necessary medical treatment afterwards?

    • Lars Littlefield

      These days it appears so. Trump isn’t really president. He’s just being provocative.

      BTW: Cative is a suburb outside of Provo, Ut.

      • RoFaWh

        So she (and her hubby) are likely momos.

  • Mickey Bitsko
  • -M-

    Well she has the willful ignorance and total lack of morals to take her husband’s former position in the Drumpf maladministration.

  • Lars Littlefield

    Whereas I miss those day in the middle ages when people like her were stripped naked and hung in public by their labia majori, left swinging in the wind to die until they dried into jerky for being a witch. Then at that point they did not pose a risk to others for being a witch. Good times . . . good times . . . .

  • SoCalGal20

    So San Diego is in the midst of a Hep A epidemic, centered on the homeless community. You know what they doing? They’re not quarantining people. The Health Department is going out into the field, locating vulnerable people and vaccinating and educating them. It’s putting wash stations in parks and other areas where infected people might frequent and others could be exposed. It’s literally powerwashing streets with a bleach solution. It’s talking to other municipalities like Los Angeles to find out how they have combated outbreaks. There has been some criticism that they were slow to reapond and that they don’t have enough personnel to respond adequately to the epidemic but they’re not calling to quarantine people or round up the homeless.

    • sdnative1958

      We knew about the issue in March but held off on getting real about it ’til after the tourist season (and ComicCon don’t’cha know) was over.

      • SoCalGal20

        The outbreak actually started last November. So yeah…not saying the city and Health Dept were doing everything they could have but they are on it now. The last time I was at Balboa Park I saw the wash stations (which I think are a great idea for parks and public areas in general tbh).

        • MBear

          Was just in Balboa Park yesterday. Wash stations: great! White str8 obvs non-homeless guys who dont wash their hands after using the restroom: nasty

    • Lars Littlefield

      That is very interesting. SLC is working hard at keeping an outbreak spreading among the homeless who gather around the Rio Grande business district and park. Locals are incensed that the Dept of Health is setting up a shelter specifically for those suffering from the disease. Mormons are obviously in line with Mrs. Price’s thinking. Bleach!

    • BudClark

      I have said for YEARS that this is EXACTLY what happens when you DON’T treat the poor and the homeless. South of Market in San Diego is a CESSPOOL, because the homeless have been driven OUT of the rest of the county.

  • Jim Maloney

    She looks like a happy camper camping like most with her mindset do. (I’m just being provocative.)

  • Barry William Teske

    Oh look!
    In a kind of sentence.
    Such potential.
    Now, about those foot prints…

  • JAKvirginia

    Oh, I don’t know, sweetie. Maybe you should do some research before you open your piehole. Then you might discover that when AIDS came to America we had a President (Raygun) who didn’t care. Start there, hmmm?

  • JWC

    knowing the administration she works in what an asshole her husbands is Lets just say I highly question her statemeny that she she was misquotes BULLSHIT

  • Mike

    Oh Betty. She doesn’t know what quarantine means. Or what “carrier” means. Or how HIV is spread or who can spread it. Or that you can’t sentence people to life in prison for having been infected by a virus. And she comes up with her insights as her political team works to deny “treatment” to as many people as they possibly can.

    Poor, slow, dimwitted Betty. Even if she were to start reading now, she’d never catch up.

  • IamSmartypants

    She wasn’t being provocative, she was testing the waters to gauge the public reaction. We have to be constantly vigilant against this sort nonsense or the next step will be drawing up plans for camps — “Just to be provocative.”

    • DaddyRay

      Exactly – this was exactly what she would do but was looking to she was looking to gin up support

  • shellback
    • pj

      tiki nazi

    • BudClark


  • Ninja0980

    No bitch, you were putting your bigotry on display for all to see and nothing ore.

    • DaddyRay

      Sorry about the Yankees – I was really looking forward to the Yanks wiping the field with the Dodgers

      • Ninja0980

        The writing was on the wall after game 6.
        Bottom line, we had trouble winning games on the road all year and it finally bit us in the butt.

  • SFBruce

    She talks about the responsibility of those with hiv to seek treatment, but nothing about the responsibility of Alabama to ensure that everyone, including those with hiv, has access to affordable, adequate health care.

    • -M-

      Georgia has the misfortune of her presence.

  • Frank McCormick

    In my mind, she’s not really a medical doctor (although she is an MD). She is an anesthesiologist. Someone who’s job is to know drugs and never have to talk to her patients.

    • Michael McReavy

      I suppose any medical specialist could perform their duties in a mechanistic way, having minimal interaction with their patient. Jeepers, I recently saw an article by a psychiatrist who wanted education in that field to dispense with training in psychotherapy and put more emphasis on learning about drugs!

      I’ve had a couple major surgeries and in each case, there was a brief meeting with the anesthesiologist. Price really is a medical doctor but she’s also an asshole. Simple as that.

    • Skeptical_Inquirer

      I’m surprised some “undesirable” people didn’t die on the operating table because of her. Or maybe there were some we don’t know about.

  • j.martindale

    The fact that a doctor doesn’t realize that the people who receive treatment are largely NOT the people who are transmitting the disease to newly infected individuals shows she has NO BUSINESS in the public health field. She is a dumb bitch, on top of being a goddamn heartless bitch. But she is a f*cking Repuglican, which says it all.

    • RoFaWh

      Her medical training apparently didn’t include a segment on epidemiology. That or it had one but she learned nothing in it.

      • clay

        It would have required a segment on professional development and life-long learning, in which she also learned nothing.

  • JT

    GEORGIA: GOP State Rep Defends Her Suggestion To Quarantine HIV+ People: I Was Just Being Provocative

    She should be quarantined for ugliness, stupidity and just plain evil.

    • Friday

      Well, I *guess* you could call “Damn near genocidal” ‘provocative? 🙂

    • RoFaWh

      When it comes down to it, she’s defending the indefensible.

  • j.martindale

    Someone tell this bitch that a good way to fix the problem of out of control health care costs is to regulate big Pharma.

  • Karl Dubhe

    I was willing to give her the bennie of the doubt…

    Why? I’ve far too much grey hair to be so fucking naive. Grrrrr.

  • Hank

    She is taking a page out of Herr Drumpf’s book, as he claims “it was just a joke”!!! May that Witch get stuck by an infected needle!!!

  • DaveMiller135

    She should feel free to supply the context she feels is missing. But if I’m to take this non-apology seriously, she needs to give specifics about her personal actions towards prevention and stigma-reduction. Otherwise, she needs to take a moment and die more readily.

  • TrueWords

    I posted this on her Facebook page:

    Go on over and have it…

  • Mike Rasor

    You’re going to be provocative by demonizing a group who has faced discrimination along the exact same lines you outlined. It’s not a threat just a rhetorical statement. Bitch please. The rest of us aren’t as stupid as your base.

  • 5moreminutes*imtired

    Being provocative is wearing a pair of fuck me pumps and showing some cleavage. You were showing your complete lack of empathy and black soul.

  • Danieruw

    Poor baby. Bigot got caught being a bigot. If only they had people in positions of power to help them overcome all the societal oppression they face. Repulsive human being!

    • RoFaWh

      What they really want is the power to prevent the press and media from reporting such insanity. Trump’s working on it.

  • j.martindale

    She wasn’t being provocative. She was demonstrating the universal contempt that repuglicans have for gay people.

  • Bad Tom

    “too many of our fellow citizens who have HIV are not compliant.”

    “I don’t want to say the quarantine word, but I guess I just said it. Is there an ability, since I would guess that public dollars are expended heavily in prophylaxis and treatment of this condition? So we have a public interest in curtailing the spread. What would you advise or are there any methods legally that we could do that would curtail the spread?”

    GOP State Rep Betty Price

    Non-compliant patients are not expending prophylaxis dollars, private or public. THAT IS THE PROBLEM, you fool!

  • j.martindale

    HIV people may want to arm themselves. Second Amendment remedies against this government may be necessary. (Of course, I am just saying this to be provocative.)

  • Achilles Tsakiridis

    A cattle prod and a bad case of “blue waffles”… Now all we need is a Nona with a god maliocchi spell to make it happen

  • “I was just kidding!”
    Take that excuse, roll it up really tightly, and shove it up your ass as far as it will go and then 3 inches further.

  • PeedeResistance

    A tertiary-syphilitic, pustulent, cunning runt.

  • thatotherjean

    Um. . .no. Provocative is not the same as stupid and bigoted.

  • No More GOP.

    No, hon, you weren’t being provocative. You were showing us what geraniums are blooming in that cranium. It’s clear you’d like us all rounded up and dealt with.

  • GanymedeRenard
  • andrew

    Be careful when you choose your medical doctor folks. Some of them are bigots, some are bat shit crazy and some are both.

    • Jay Mills

      Ain’t that the truth.

    • RoFaWh

      When I had my first appointment with my present doctor as a new patient over thirty years ago, I asked him “I’m gay, and one of the specific hazards of being gay is anal gonorrhea. How would you test for that?”

      I later confessed to him I didn’t give a damn about the ostensible point of my question; I was just testing him to see if he had any homophobic tendencies.

      He passed with flying colors and has been my GP for a very long time now.

  • Hue-Man

    If this Republican mouthpiece says that HIV+ people should be quarantined, you know that concentration camps are already being constructed and the Log Cabin Republicans are deciding what font to use on the welcome signs.
    Arbeit macht frei

    • GanymedeRenard

      I wonder if they’re already manufacturing the pink triangles.

      • lenvus

        No, because they refuse to remember the old adage, “History Repeats Itself.” The Log Cabin Republicans still believe its cool and hip to appear at pride parades to say, they too, still support the LGBTQ community. No, they are constructing rainbow triangles. They have to keep their hatred “up with the times,” you know…

        • GanymedeRenard

          I’d like for them to receive rainbow pyramids. Made out of cactus. To use immediately.

    • Jay Mills

      All you have to do is be “compliant”. See, problem solved.

  • RoFaWh

    Ooopsie! Poor dear. Here she thought she was saying something that would bring her applause and approval and, poor dear, she’s having shit flung at her. Time to backpedal.

    • CCleverly

      She was just following the Trump example.

  • Mike_in_the_Tundra

    “died more readily”

    That’s the quote that bothers me.

    • clay

      Even in her response, when she claims it was about compliance, that phrase pretty much says it was NOT about compliance.

  • Halou

    So we have a public interest in curtailing the spread. What would you advise or are there any methods legally that we could do that would curtail the spread?”

    One idea would be to ignore the lobbying of religious institutions that have, since the very beginning of HIV & AIDS tried to cut research funding, shut down any and all awareness campaigns and have targeted clinics providing care, support, advice and medication to those who need it.

    Don’t quarantine gays, quarantine the church.

  • MB
  • DN

    Eat shit, whore.

    Oh, but it’s OK – I was just being provocative.

  • Bill Haffey

    There was a phrase that was popular during the height of the AIDS/HIV pandemic, among “good Christian folk” like her. “The up side of AIDS is it is killing all the right people.” The folks that should be quarantined are people like her, so their hate and false Christianity can be wiped of the face of the earth.

  • Statistics Palin

    I am being recruited by a company in Atlanta. I make 5 1/2 times the median income for Georgia and my collaborator, who is HIV+, makes 7 times that amount. I am sending this explanation along with the AJC article about Betty Price to explain why I will never work in or move to Georgia.

  • LovesIrony

    I don’t want to use the shithead word, but I guess I just said it.

  • Oh, no, honey! You weren’t being provocative. You were being a fascist bigoted homophobe whose “modest proposal” to quarantine everyone with HIV inevitably brought to mind Nazi concentration camps.

  • Benny S.

    Move over Dr. Ben Carson. You’ve been replaced.

  • supasugacrisp

    Price said she was just being “provocative.” Hope your career pays for it!!!!!

  • John

    In the past, Republicans would die in their late 50s or early 60s. So, they did not live long enough to spread their stupidity. Too bad they don’t die as young now.

  • Jean-Marc in Canada

    “Provocative” my firm downy white ass, you cucking funt.

  • Bert_Bauer

    Gee, Pat Buchanan should have thought of that excuse when he made the same idiotic recommendation in the early 80’s. I think I need to start screening my medical providers for political affiliation.

  • Dan McPeek

    A suggestion, Mrs. Price Is Wrong: Quit buying your wigs at the dollar store.
    Or…you will have to be quarantined. You are spreading extreme ugliness.
    Or am I being too provocative?

  • Skeptical_Inquirer

    Who does she think she is? Milo?

    Also, the people who voted for her should be side eyed and asked if they agree with this shit.

  • Gianni

    She,herself, needn’t worry. Nobody would even revenge fuck her.

  • Wynter Marie Starr

    No, asshole. You are NOT being provocative. You are showing your true bigoted colors. Along with your lack of empathy and humanity, you are showing us just what you are; an inexcusable subhuman who lacks everything that makes the rest of us us human,

  • fuzzybits

    We hear you the first time you lying asswipe.

  • BuffaloDan

    She asks for a “quarantine,” which is _literally_ a forty day period until a disease (originally, the Black Plague) manifests. So many individuals have been living with HIV and other health issues for years, and overcoming them for decades, despite individuals like her. (Maybe the same with diabetes and other chronic conditions; they couldn’t be ameliorated in the past, but we can “manage” many of these illnesses now — again, despite, individuals like her. Stupid science! It costs so much, right?)

    Is it forty days from the manifestation of the illness — or forty days after one admits it? Oh, Rep. Price, you really don’t know what words mean, do you? If it helps, I know what feckless incompetence means. Want me to explain it for you?

    I’d like to talk about how long that I think right-wing fascists should be “quarantined.” Let’s talk!

  • Vista-Cruiser

    This was a calculated political maneuver to boost her name recognition and conservative bona fides. She knows that the political winds are blowing more and more toward fascism. This being Georgia, don’t be surprised to see her win a seat in the US Congress using this platform.

    • 2guysnamedjoe

      The context in which she said it was:
      “Ooh, did I say that? (Tee-hee!) I didn’t mean it that way! (big stage wink)”

  • BudClark

    Well, Carverville still exists, doesn’t it?

    • 2guysnamedjoe

      What’s Carverville, Bud? (My friend Google wasn’t much help on this one.)

      • BudClark

        I may have misspelled it, but it was / is the old leper colony somewhere down South. They keep it open because the older lepers feel safe there, though they are (now) free to leave if they want to.

    • 2guysnamedjoe

      What’s Carverville, Bud? (My friend Google wasn’t much help on this one.)

  • KaBoomBOX

    She should lose her medical license.

  • olandp

    So there is a context in which her statement sounds good?

    • Snarkaholic

      Yes…when the voices in her head tell her that she’s brilliant.

  • Oscarlating Wildely

    “too many of our fellow citizens who have HIV are not compliant.”

    Oh, okay, I give: What the fuck does that one mean? Non-compliant with what? Or is it a who?
    And Hon, quit pissing off The Gayz. Your hair looks like shit. Help is clearly needed.

    • Duck

      I have 2 guesses.

      1) non compliant with treatment is the most generous of the 2.

      2) non compliant with dying “more readily” is more likely what she really means

    • 2guysnamedjoe

      Let’s see your voting record on sex-ed, reproductive health and Planned Parenthood funding, Mrs. Fuckface-Provocative, and we’ll discuss their effects on “compliance”.

      • Snarkaholic

        I don’t think she can call herself totally against birth control…
        …after all, that face of hers is the ULTIMATE contraceptive!

  • Vinnie NYC

    My choice words for her. Eff you whore

    • 2guysnamedjoe

      Ooh, you’re so pro-VOCCA-tive!!

  • JamieL

    And when I say we should imprison all cunty bitches that hate gays, I’m just being provocative.

    • Snarkaholic

      And remember, you can’t spell provocative without proactive!

  • Andymac3

    Is it really a surprise that former HHS Secretary and total elitist shit head grifter Tom Price is married to a psychopathic woman who thinks gay people should be treated like cattle and deserve to die sooner than later? She actually said “My thinking sometimes goes in strange directions, but before you proceed if you wouldn’t mind commenting on the surveillance of partners, tracking of contacts, that sort of thing. What are we legally able to do (with gays)?”

    And why isn’t hubby in jail for insider trading and misusing $1million of tax payers money for trips to his own properties and lunches with family and friends. Do these people pay for anything?

  • gothambear

    Here is her office phone number at the Coverdell Legislative Office in Atlanta 404-656-0202

  • Jefe5084

    You were probably never provocative, ever in your life. Give it up. At least for one definition for the word.

    The other definition? No, you’re just showing what a couple of shitheads you and your creepy husband are.

    • Snarkaholic

      She’s just pissed because her gay stylist (intentionally and gleefully) keeps giving her that atrocious haircut.

  • Ann Kah

    That wasn’t “provocative”. That was asinine. “Provocative” would be to make reasonable suggestions that might actually succeed and be effective, and that would make others think in more depth about how to implement those suggestions. You wouldn’t know “provocative” if it snuggled up on your pillow tonight.

  • 2guysnamedjoe

    Racism, homophobia and fascism are communicable diseases that lead ultimately to massive morbidity and mortality. Carriers should be immediately isolated, physically and electronically, from the general population.

    • Snarkaholic

      Don’t forget greed.

  • xzargo

    Stupid bitch.

  • SDG

    Here’s provocative… for you, how about the quarantine of all nasty, ugly, mean, homophobic, racist white bitches?

  • JAKvirginia

    Provocative. You keep using that word but I don’t think you know what it means.

  • EdA

    Here’s something provocative for you. Physicians who believe that people with illnesses should be jailed and not treated should not be allowed to practice on live human beings or animals.

  • seant426

    More people per annum die from pneumonia, so let’s quarantine them, you dumb bitch.

  • Nick

    I wrote her. Here was her response:

    Representative Price,

    You’re a vulgar person and a terrible liar. The fact that you hold a medical degree and don’t know how HIV is being prevented (PrEP, Condoms, Education) is vile.

    Your statements were not “provocative.” There is nothing about you that is provocative. You’re just an awful human being.


    Nickolas Vannello
    Cleveland, OH

    PS. Grow up and join the world of Twitter. If you are too incompetent to run your own account, hire someone. The next time you say something stupid, you’ll get feedback much quicker.

    Why have the new cases each year not decreased? That is the issue.

    After 30+ years, it would be great if this virus could be eradicated.

    It serves no purpose to make me the story. We have a serious public health issue that does not seem to be going away.

    Rep. Betty Price, M.D. (48)
    Georgia General Assembly
    18 Capitol Square
    Suite 507 CLOB
    Atlanta, GA 30334
    404-656-0202 (o)
    [email protected]


    You ARE the story because you are a physician.

    The number of cases HAS decreased – 10% from 2010 to 2014, and with drugs like PrEP (Truvada), you can expect that number to decrease further and more rapidly.

    Yes, it would be great if the virus would have been eradicated. You want to know why it wasn’t? Because Reagan didn’t have the balls to say AIDS during his presidency until it was too late. Because people like you made this a “gay” disease and god knows, you wouldn’t want to help the faggots. Because people like you continue to treat this disease like a joke and a punchline.

    You ARE the story because you should know better and you are expected to act intelligently. We have had a serious health issue for 30 years and you still treat it like the people suffering from it have done something wrong. Why didn’t you propose that cancer victims from smoking or alcoholics be quarantined?

    You ARE the story. You MADE yourself the story. And until YOU do something about it, it’s not going to go away.


    Nickolas Vannello

    PS: Tell me, how much funding have you personally donated towards HIV research? What do you know about Truvada (without having to look it up)?

  • 3-Star

    History repeats itself – California Proposition 64 (1986)

  • Pete Wascher

    my god! idiocy, not HIV, is spread by marriage, it seems.

  • Criticize a bigot’s words and prepare to be accused of having taken the words out of context. Classic move. Never trust homophobes for they will cut you!

  • Nate

    “too many of our fellow citizens who have HIV are not compliant.”

    What is this supposed to mean? Even if she just meant they aren’t on medication, not everyone can be because our health care system is so terrible. But I think she means something much more troubling.

  • AmeriCanadian

    People, people. She was actually saying that she’s pro-vodka-tive, not provocative.

  • amati1684

    Provocative? How stupid can she be? The Republican Party will die long before we do, and it will be because of idiotic statements such as Betty Price makes.

  • TrollopeReader

    Can we please just quarantine 21st c Confederates? Life would be much easier all around …

  • Professor Barnhardt

    “taken completely out of context” = I said it.

  • Mac

    I was aghast when I first read this, but I guess I shouldn’t be. These people have been having their hatred of anyone “different” (read: non-white, non-male, and/or non-allegedly heterosexual) through 8 years of an articulate, thoughtful, HUMAN (but black) president and his family and administration. And marriage equality. Poor little things, feeling their power dwindling away. Easier to hate and rail against something than to fix it for all. Betty Price should remember that 100 years ago, she couldn’t own property, vote or get a divorce without a man’s permission.

  • newtosf921

    I am not only disturbed by what she said, but I am understanding she is a doctor! I am guessing by her ignorance she went to the same medical school as Dr. Ben Carson-the school of idioticy! I wouldn’t let Carson or Mrs. Price remove a splinter from my finger. And, what about heterosexual people that continue to have sex when they have STDs!!?!?!??

  • wds

    And what the h**l does she even know about this? Info she’s picked up from Infowars or “God Hates … She’s as worthless as her husband … SMH

  • cleos_mom

    If she wants to be “provocative”, she should just invest in a pole. There are even ideas for cute outfits available on Pinterest.